|
Post by killerzzz on Dec 7, 2007 4:49:38 GMT
Who, me? Well, in short...
1. Socerer's Stone: My second fav. It has the most magical feel, experiancing all the new things, but it is a bit kiddish, which is its only down for me.
2. Chamber of Secrets: Not bad. The hissing was dumb. Shoulda held it back for the end, like in the book. Got lame in the movie. Otherwise, pretty ok.
3. Prisonner of Azkaban: My fav movie. It was dark, serious, action packed, scary/cool. Downs? The change of the Hogwards grounds, especially the minimizing of the Womping Willow. Alos the loss of the previous, cooler Dumbledore.
4. Goblet of Fire: More like, Harry Potter and the Attack of the Raging Hormones, mirite?!!
5. Order of the Pheonix: Again, not bad. A few things missing, but whatev. I can't wait for 6.
So, yeah, in a nutshell... ;D
Killerzzz
|
|
|
Post by hector on Dec 7, 2007 7:32:03 GMT
Philosopher's Stone/Chamber of Secrets: Put this two together because they are basically the same. Dry, painful and boring. Columbus manages to suck all the amazement and wonder of the world created by Rowling. A guy reading the books aloud would've been better. I still give some props to Chamber for being the one HP movie so far without any gigantic plothole because the screenwriter didn't decide to put one extra line of dialogue.
Prisoner of Azkaban: The first truly great Harry Potter movie, and an extremely well done movie in general. Cuaron's touch was excellent and brought some much needed depth to the world and the characters. I'm still clinging to faint hopes that he could return to direct the seventh.
Goblet of Fire: A good, entertaining summer movie, with lots of action and some good character. Plus, Ralph Fiennes as Voldemort is brilliant.
Order of the Phoenix: Second best after Azkaban. The three leads developed into some really fine actors and it shows the strongest here. Also, almost all of Harry's unending whining from the book is eliminated. However, it was about half an hour too short.
|
|
|
Post by Konrad Flameheart on Dec 11, 2007 8:44:30 GMT
I actually have to agree with Hec on this one (or five) the only thing i would add is that although i liked Goblet of fire the fact that the best shot scene was relativly near the begining doesn't say much for the rest of the film (the entrance of the other schools to hogwarts....Gotta love those Kombat Mage's).
|
|